In this BULLYMAKE Box review, we look at whether a subscription designed specifically for power chewers can save dog owners from constantly replacing destroyed toys. Instead of sending the same plush toys found in many subscription boxes, BULLYMAKE focuses on tougher toys selected around your dog’s size and chewing habits.
For owners who are used to watching a new toy get torn apart within minutes, the appeal is simple. Some dogs can make a brand new toy look like it’s been through a war in less than an hour. You bring home something labeled “durable,” your dog gets excited, and before long you’re picking pieces off the floor and wondering why you spent money on it in the first place. BULLYMAKE is designed to give aggressive chewers toys that can keep them entertained longer while reducing the cycle of constantly buying replacements.
BULLYMAKE is built specifically for those dogs. Each subscription box can be customized around your dog’s size, chewing style, toy preferences, and allergies, then filled with durable toys and treats designed with power chewers in mind. Instead of repeatedly searching for another toy that might survive, BULLYMAKE keeps a fresh rotation of tougher options arriving at your door.
Affiliate Disclosure: ProductPanther may earn a commission when you purchase through links on this page, at no additional cost to you.
Key Features
Built for Power Chewers
Give tough dogs tougher toys
BULLYMAKE offers different toy types based on how your dog plays, including heavy duty nylon and rubber options for dogs that aggressively chew through ordinary toys.
Customized for Your Dog
Get toys that actually fit their play style
Choose toy preferences based on chewing strength and play style, while allergy information can also be added to help tailor eligible treat selections.
New Themes and Toys
Give them something new to get excited about
Every box brings a new theme and a fresh selection, helping keep new toys rotating into the house instead of relying on the same old pile.
45 Day Toy Guarantee
Put the toys to the test
If an eligible BULLYMAKE toy is destroyed or simply isn’t a good fit, BULLYMAKE offers a replacement when a qualifying claim is made within 45 days of receiving it.
When “Durable” Usually Lasts About 20 Minutes
You know the routine. You find a toy that looks tough enough, bring it home, hand it to your dog, and watch them immediately begin working on the weakest part. Not long after, there’s stuffing on the floor or another destroyed toy heading toward the trash.
That’s what makes BULLYMAKE different from simply buying another random dog toy. You tell them what kind of chewer you have and what types of toys your dog prefers, then new options continue showing up as part of the subscription. If you don’t want treats, there’s even a Toys Only option focused entirely on keeping the toy rotation stocked.
Who Is the BULLYMAKE Box Best For?
Power Chewers
The obvious fit, dogs that chew aggressively and routinely make quick work of conventional toys.
Dogs That Get Bored Easily
Regularly introducing different toys can give dogs more variety instead of leaving the same toys sitting around month after month.
Picky Players
Customization makes BULLYMAKE useful for dogs that strongly prefer certain kinds of play, whether that’s chewing, tugging, fetching, or softer toys.
Owners Tired of Buying Replacements
Best for someone who already spends money replacing dog toys and would rather have new options delivered automatically.
BULLYMAKE Box Review: Subscription Details
| Product Type | Dog Toy Subscription |
| Standard Box | 2 to 3 Tough Toys + 3 Treats |
| Toys Only Option | Available (4 to 5 Toys) |
| Customization | Chew Style, Toy Preference & Allergies |
| Box Themes | New Theme Each Month |
| Delivery | Typically Every 30 Days (Every 2 or 3 Months Available) |
| Toy Guarantee | 45 Days |
| Refund Window | 3 Days, Unused and Unopened |
BULLYMAKE Box Pricing
BULLYMAKE offers several subscription lengths, with longer commitments reducing the monthly price. The standard Toys & Treats Box is currently listed at $45 for a one month subscription, with lower monthly pricing available on longer plans. BULLYMAKE also regularly runs introductory promotions, so the first box may cost considerably less than the normal subscription price. Because offers and plan pricing can change, check the current deal and renewal terms before subscribing.
Explore more of our best pet products for other ProductPanther picks for feeding, play, monitoring, and everyday pet care.